Who are we as historical beings? Shaping identities in light of the archaeogenetics ‘revolution’
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.37718/CSA.2019.01Keywords:
aDNA, archaeology, identity, narratives, reductionism, slow scienceAbstract
There is a human fundamental need to know who we are and where we come from. In an age when myths, legends and family memories are starting to fade or become obsolete, science is brought in to fill the gaps and answer these questions. This article introduces a special theme section dedicated to critical reflections on the relationship between the disciplines of archaeology and archaeogenetics. It gives a summary of the ‘Can science accommodate multiple ontologies? The genetics revolution and archaeological theory’ workshop held in Cambridge 2018, followed by an introduction of the papers in this theme section. Lastly, I evaluate archaeogenetic narratives in terms of their target audience, knowledge obtained (or not) and future directions.
Downloads
References
Androshchuk, F. 2018. Female Viking Revisited. Viking and Medieval Scandinavia. Vol. 14 pp. 47-60.
Atlantic 2018. Ancient DNA is Rewriting Human (and Neanderthal) History. 14 March 2018. Available at: https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/03/ancient-dna-history/554798/ [Accessed 1 February 2019].
Austin, R.M., Sholts, S.B., Williams, L., Kistler, L. & Hofman, C.A. 2019. Opinion: To Curate the Molecular Past, Museums need a carefully considered set of Best Practices. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Vol. 116(5) pp. 1471-1474.
Barras, C. 2018. Ancient ‘dark-skinned’ Briton Cheddar Man find may not be true. New Scientist. 21 February 2018. https://www.newscientist.com/article/2161867-ancient-dark-skinned-briton-cheddar-man-find-may-not-be-true/ [Accessed 10 February 2019].
BBC 2013. Making of Europe unlocked by DNA. 23 April 2013. Available at: https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-22252099 [Accessed 10 February 2019].
Bhattacharya, S., Li, J., […] Butte, A.J., & Nolan, G.P. 2018. Whole-genome Sequencing of Atacama Skeleton Shows Novel Mutations Linked with Dysplasia. Genome Research. Vol. 28(4) pp. 423–431.
Booth, T.J. 2019. A Stranger in a Strange Land: A Perspective on Archaeological Responsesto the Palaeogenetic Revolution from an Archaeologist working amongst Palaeogeneticists. World Archaeology. DOI: 10.1080/00438243.2019.1627240.
Bramanti, B., Thomas, M.G., […] Forster, P. & Burger, J. 2009.Genetic Discontinuity between Local Hunter-Gatherers and Central Europe’s First Farmers. Science. 326(5949) pp. 137-40.
Brown University 2017. Call for Papers: State of the Field 2019: The Ancient DNA Revolution in Archaeology. https://blogs.brown.edu/archaeology/2018/08/13/cfp2019/ [Accessed 5 December 2018].
Buzzfeednews 2019 How not to Talk about Race and Genetics. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/bfopinion/race-genetics-david-reich [Accessed 10 January 2019].
Callaway, E. 2018. Divided by DNA: The Uneasy Relationship between Archaeology and Ancient Genomics. Nature, 28 March 2018. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-03773-6 [Accessed 30 March 2018].
Cavazzuti, C., Skeates, R., […] Cardarelli, A. & Salzani, L. 2019. Flows of People in Villages and Large Centres in Bronze Age Italy through Strontium and Oxygen Isotopes. PLoS ONE 14(1) e.0209693.
Current Archaeology 2018. Prehistoric Pop Culture: Deciphering the DNA of the Bell Beaker Complex. https://www.archaeology.co.uk/articles/prehistoric-pop-culture-deciphering-the-dna-of-the-bell-beaker-complex.htm [Accessed 10 September 2019].
Currie, A. & Sterelny, K. 2017. In Defence of Story-telling. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A. Vol. 62 pp. 14–21.
Cutaș, D.E. 2018. Istoria din Noi. Sceuna9, 12 September 2018. https://www.scena9.ro/article/genealogie-familie-adn [Accessed 10 January 2019].
Dailymail 2018. DNA map of Ireland reveals the Irish have Viking and Norman Ancestry and are far more genetically diverse than previously thought. 25 January 2018. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-5312697/DNA-map-Britain-Ireland-reveals-Viking-genes.html [Accessed 10 February 2019].
Demény, P. 2019. „Să Nu Confundăm Imaginea Mass-Media Despre Societate Cu Societatea Insăși”. abcentenar, 22 ianuarie 2019. https://abcentenar.wordpress.com/2019/01/22/sa-nu-confundam-imaginea-mass-media-despre-societate-cu-societatea-insasi/ [Accessed 22 January 2019].
Dorador, C. 2018. The Girl from la Noria. 25 March 2018. https://www.etilmercurio.com/em/the-girl-from-la-noria/ [Accessed 7 February 2019]
Eisenmann, S., Bánffy, E., […] Reich, D. & Stockhammer, P.W. 2018. Reconciling Material Cultures in Archaeology with Genetic Data: The Nomenclature of Clusters Emerging from Archaeogenomic Analysis. Scientific Reports. Vol. 8 no. 13003.
Frieman, C.J. & Hofmann, D. 2019. Present Pasts in the Archaeology of Genetics, Identity, and Migration in Europe: a Critical Essay. World Archaeology. DOI: 10.1080/00438243.2019.1627907.
Furholt, M. 2018. Massive Migrations? The Impact of Recent aDNA Studies on our View of Third Millennium Europe. European Journal of Archaeology. Vol. 21(2) pp. 159-191.
Furholt, M. 2019. Re-integrating Archaeology: A Contribution to aDNA Studies and the Migration Discourse on the 3rd Millennium BC in Europe. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society. pp. 1-15. doi:10.1017/ppr.2019.4
Haak, W., Balanovsky, O., [...] Alt, K.W., & Cooper, A. 2010. Ancient DNA from European Early Neolithic Farmers Reveals Their Near Eastern Affinities. PLoS Biol. Vol. 8(11 no: e1000536.
Haak, W., Lazaridis, I., […] Alt, K.W. & Reich, D. 2015. Massive Migration from the Steppe was a Source for Indo-European Languages in Europe. Nature. Vol. 522 pp. 207–211.
Hagelberg, E., Hofreiter, M. & Keyser, C. 2015. Ancient DNA: The First Three Decades. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences. Vol. 370(1660) no. 20130371.
Hakenbeck, S. 2019. Genetics, Archaeology and the Far Right: An Unholy Trinity. World Archaeology. doi.org/10.1080/00438243.2019.1617189.
Halcrow, S. E., Killgrove, […] Jungers, W. & Gunterg, J. 2018. On Engagement with Anthropology: A Critical Evaluation of Skeletal and Developmental Abnormalities in the Atacama Preterm Baby and Issues of Forensic and Bioarchaeological Research Ethics. Response to Bhattacharya et al. “Whole-genome sequencing of Atacama skeleton shows novel mutations linked with dysplasia” in Genome Research, 2018, 28: 423–431. Doi: 10.1101/gr.223693.117. International Journal of Paleopathology. Vol. 22 pp. 97-100.
Harland, J.M. 2017. “Race” in the Trenches: Anglo-Saxons, Ethnicity, and the Misuse of the Medieval Past. 17 February 2017. https://www.publicmedievalist.com/race-in-the-trenches/ [Accessed 7 February 2019].
Hawks J. 2019. How can Archaeologists make a Difference to Media and Public Perceptions of ancient DNA? The SAA Archaeological Record 19(1): 39–43.
Heritage Daily 2017. Ancient DNA Analysis Reveals Minoan and Mycenaean Origins, 2 August 2017. https://www.heritagedaily.com/2017/08/ancient-dna-analysis-reveals-minoan-mycenaean-origins/116193 [Accessed 18 January 2019].
Hervella, M., Rotea, M., […] Netea, M.G. & de-la-Rua, C. 2015. Ancient DNA from South-East Europe Reveals Different Events during Early and Middle Neolithic Influencing the European Genetic Heritage. PLoS One. Vol. 10(6) no. e0128810.
Heyd, V. 2017. Kossinna’s Smile. Antiquity. Vol. 91(356) pp. 348–359.
Hills, C. 2009. Anglo-Saxon DNA? In: Sayer, D. & Williams, H. (eds). Mortuary Practices and Social Identities in the middle Ages, pp. 123-140. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.
Hoffman, D. 2015. What have Genetics Ever Done for Us? The Implications of aDNA Data for Interpreting Identity in Early Neolithic Central Europe. European Journal of Archaeology. Vol 18(3) pp. 454–476.
Horejs, B. 2019. Archäologie Zwischen 'Genetischem Goldrausch' und Ethischem Dilemma. https://science.apa.at/dossier/Archaeologie_zwischen_genetischem_Goldrausch_und_ethischem_Dilemma [Accessed 2 February 2019].
Ion, A. 2017a. How Interdisciplinary is Interdisciplinarity? Revisiting the Impact of aDNA Research for the Archaeology of Human Remains. Current Swedish Archaeology. Vol. 25 pp. 177-198.
Ion, A. 2017b. And Then They Were Bodies: Medieval Royalties, from DNA Analysis to a Nation’s Identity. In: Mroziewicz, K. & Sroczyński, A. (eds). Premodern Rulership and Contemporary Political Power: The King’s Body Never Dies, pp. 217–237. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
Iusuf, S. 2018. Cine Esti? Dilema veche 773, 13-19 December 2018. https://dilemaveche.ro/sectiune/societate/articol/cine-esti [Accessed 15 December 2018].
Jesch, J. 2017. Let’s Debate Female Viking Warriors Yet Again. Norse and Viking Ramblings, blogpost 9/9. http://norseandviking.blogspot.com/2017/09/lets-debate-female-viking-warriors-yet.html [Accessed 22 September 2019].
Jones, E.D. 2019. Ancient Genetics to Ancient Genomics: Celebrity and Credibility in Data-Driven Practice. Biology & Philosophy. Vol. 34(2) article 27, doi.org/10.1007/s10539-019-9675-1.
Klejn, L., Haak, W., […] Kristiansen, K. & Willerslev, E. 2018. Discussion: Are the Origins of Indo-European Languages Explained by the Migration of the Yamnaya Culture to the West? European Journal of Archaeology. Vol. 21(1) pp. 3-17.
Leonelli, S. 2016. Data-Centric Biology: A Philosophical Study. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Lewis-Kraus. G. 2019. Is Ancient DNA Research Revealing New Truths- or Falling Into Old Traps? New York Times, 17 January 2019. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/17/magazine/ancient-dna-paleogenomics.html [Accessed 19 January 2019].
Lidén, K. & Eriksson, G. 2013. Archaeology vs. Archaeological Science: Do We Have a Case? Current Swedish Archaeology. Vol. 21 pp. 11-20.
Lucas, G. 2019. Writing the Past. Knowledge and Literary Production in Archaeology. New York: Routledge.
MacAllister, J.W. 2018. Scientists’ Reuse of Old Empirical Data: Epistemological Aspects. Philosophy of Science. Vol. 85 pp. 755–766.
Malmström, H., Linderholm, A., […] Lidén, K. & Götherström, A. 2015. Ancient Mitochondrial DNA from the Northern Fringe of the Neolithic Farming Expansion in Europe Sheds Light on the Dispersion Process. Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences. Vol. 370(1660) no. 20130373.
McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research 2018. Workshop ‘Can science accommodate multiple ontologies? The genetics revolution and archaeological theory’. https://geneticsandarchaeology.wordpress.com/). [Accessed 10 January 2019]
Mediafax.ro. 2012. Haşotti nu este de acord cu prelevarea de ADN de la voievozii dinastiei Basarabilor, 28 June 2012. https://www.mediafax.ro/cultura-media/hasotti-nu-este-de-acord-cu-prelevarea-de-adn-de-la-voievozii-dinastiei-basarabilor-9793066 [Accessed 10 January 2019]
Molteni, M. 2018. So Much Genetic Testing. So Few People to explain it to You. Wired 10 October 2018. https://www.wired.com/story/so-much-genetic-testing-so-few-people-to-explain-it-to-you/. [Accessed 10 September 2019].
Naughton, J. 2019. Why it's Dangerous to liken DNA to Computer Code. The Guardian 21 September 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/sep/21/why-its-dangerous-to-liken-dna-to-computer-code [Accessed 21 September 2019].
Nelson, A. 2016. The Social Life of DNA: Race, Reparations, and Reconciliation after the Genome. Boston: Beacon Press.
Niculescu, G.A. 2018. Interdisciplinary Practices and the Autonomy of the Archaeological Research Traditions. UIPSS. https://uispp2018.sciencesconf.org/browse/session?sessionid=24440. [Accessed 5 December 2019].
Olalde, I., Brace, S., […] Lalueza-Fox, C. & Reich, D. 2018. The Beaker Phenomenon and the Genomic Transformation of Northwest Europe. Nature. Vol. 555 pp. 190–196.
Palsson, G. 2007. Anthropology and the New Genetics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Pickrell, J.K. & Reich, D. 2014. Toward a New History and Geography of Human Genes Informed by ancient DNA. Trends Genet. Vol. 30(9) pp. 377-89.
Prendergast, M.P. & Sawchuk, E. 2018. Boots on the Ground in Africa’s Ancient DNA ‘Revolution’: Archaeological Perspectives on Ethics and Best Practices. Antiquity. Vol. 92(363) pp. 803–815.
Raport științific 2014. Raport științific privind rezultatele obținute în cadrul proiectului PCCA_1153b(contract229/2013). http://www.ibiol.ro/proiecte/PNII/GENESIS/rezultate.htm [Accessed 15 September 2015].
Reich, D. 2018a. Available at: How Genetics Is Changing Our Understanding of ‘Race’ https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/23/opinion/sunday/genetics-race.html [Accessed 19 January 2019].
Reich, D. 2018b. How to Talk About ‘Race’ and Genetics. 30 March 2018. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/30/opinion/race-genetics.html [Accessed 19 January 2019].
Reich, D. 2018c. Who we are and how we got here: Ancient DNA and the New Science of the Human Past. New York: Pantheon Books.
Reich, D. 2019a. Letter in Response to Jan. 17 article in The New York Times. 19 January 2019. Available at: https://reich.hms.harvard.edu/letter-response-jan-17-article-new-york-times [Accessed 19 January 2019].
Reich, D. 2019b. Five Corrections to The New York Times. 21 January 2019. https://reich.hms.harvard.edu/five-corrections-new-york-times [Accessed 21 January 2019].
Ribeiro, A. 2018a. Archaeology and the Historical Understanding. Kiel Graduate School ‘Human Development in Landscapes’ Series 14. Kiel: Universitätsforschungen zur prähistorischen Archäologie.
Ribeiro, A. 2018b: Death of the Passive Subject: Intentional Action and Narrative Explanation in Archaeological Studies. History of the Human Sciences. Vol. 31(3) pp. 105–121.
Sayer, D. 2007. Why the Idea that the English have a Common Anglo-Saxon Origin is a Myth. 15 December 2017. https://theconversation.com/why-the-idea-that-the-english-have-a-common-anglo-saxon-origin-is-a-myth-88272 [Accessed 1 February 2019].
Serre, D. & Pääbo, S. 2004. Evidence for Gradients of Human Genetic Diversity within and Among Continents. Genome Research. Vol. 14(9) pp. 1679–1685.
Setterfield, D. 2018. Once Upon a River. New York: Atria/Emily Bestler Books.
Sheffield University 2019. DNA Tool allows you to trace your Ancient Ancestry, 14 January 2019. Sheffiled University. https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/aps/news/dna-tool-allows-you-to-trace-your-ancient-ancestry-1.825172 [Accessed 15 January 2019].
Skoglund, P., Malmström, H., […] Götherström, A. & Jakobsson, M. 2012. Origins and Genetic Legacy of Neolithic Farmers and Hunter–Gatherers in Europe. Science. Vol. 336 pp. 466–469.
Sørensen, T.F. 2017. The Two Cultures and a World Apart: Archaeology and Science at a New Crossroads. Norwegian Archaeological Review. Vol. 50(2) pp. 101–115.
Szécsényi-Nagy, A., Brandt, G., […] Bánffy, E. & Alt, K.W. 2015. Tracing the Genetic Origin of Europe's First Farmers Reveals Insights into their Social Organization. Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. Vol. 28 no. 20150339.
The Guardian 2017. How a DNA revolution has Decoded the Origins of our Humanity. 19 November 2017. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/nov/19/human-evolution-dna-revolution-mapping-genome [Accessed 7 February 2019].
The Guardian 2018. Arrival of Beaker Folk changed Britain for ever, ancient DNA study shows. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/feb/21/arrival-of-beaker-folk-changed-britain-forever-ancient-dna-study-shows [Accessed 10 September 2019].
The New York Times 2019. Why You Should be Careful about 23andMe’s Health Test. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/02/01/opinion/23andme-cancer-dna-test-brca.html [Accessed 10 September 2019].
The New York Times 2012. Family Tree of Languages has Roots in Anatolia, Biologists say. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/24/science/indo-european-languages-originated-in-anatolia-analysis-suggests.html [Accessed 10 September 2019].
The SAA Archaeological Record. Volume 19(1), January 2019. http://onlinedigeditions.com/publication/?i=563489 [Accessed 1 February 2019].
The Sun 2018. BEAK TO REALITY How the First Britons were Wiped out by Boozy Beaker People who Invaded the UK and their Blood STILL runs through us Today. https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/5638968/beaker-people-alcohol-uk-britain-stonehenge/ [Accessed 10 September 2019].
Williams, H. 2017. Viking Warrior Women: An Archaeodeath Response Part 1. Blogpost 14/9. https://howardwilliamsblog.wordpress.com/2017/09/14/viking-warrior-women-an-archaeodeath-response-part-1/ [Accessed 9 February 2019].
Wylie, A. 2015. A Plurality of Pluralisms: Collaborative Practice in Archaeology. In: Tsou, J. Y., Richardson, A. & Padovani, F. (eds). Objectivity in Science. New Perspectives from Science and Technology Studies, pp. 189-210. Cham: Springer Verlag.
Veeramah, K.R. 2018. The Importance of Fine-Scale Studies for Integrating Paleogenomics and Archaeology. Current Opinion in Genetics & Development. Vol. 53 pp. 83–89.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors contributing to Current Swedish Archaeology retain copyright of their work, with first publication rights granted to the Swedish Archaeological Society. Read the journal's full Copyright- and Licensing Policy.
