De-contaminating the aDNA – archaeology dialogue on mobility and migration: discussing the culture-historical legacy
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.37718/CSA.2019.03Keywords:
Migration, debate, 3rd millennium BC in Europe, Genetic, Culture Historian Legacy, Polythetic classificationAbstract
While the newly available ancient DNA data have shaken a lot of archaeological debates, they have, despite their enormous potential, not yet had any meaningful impact on the way we view prehistory. Instead of using this new data-source to explore new questions, or at least to re-assess the old ones, aDNA results have been tacked onto some of the most outdated narratives in European prehistory, stemming from the early twentieth century. The simplified Steppe migration narrative builds upon long-outdated culture-historical concepts, sloppy classification work, and a reliance on a monothetic culture concept which was convincingly deconstructed 50 years ago by David Clarke. In this paper, a polythetic approach to the material of the third millennium BC presents a different picture of the period. Additionally relying on a practice-based approach to how new transregional objects and practices are integrated into local contexts, it is argued that these two adjustments to our approach to the archaeological material can significantly improve the aDNA - archaeology dialogue, and better integrate the different datasets.
Downloads
References
Adamson, B. 2016. Thugs, Crooks, and Rebellious Negroes: Racist and Racialized Media Coverage of Michael Brown and the Ferguson Demonstrations. Harvard Journal of Racial and Ethnic Justice. Vol. 32 p.189.
Allentoft, M.E., Sikora, M., [...] Kristiansen, K. & Willerslev, E. 2015. Population Genomics of Bronze Age Eurasia. Nature. Vol. 522(7555) pp. 167–172.
Ansede, M. 2018. Una invasión borró del mapa a los hombres de la península Ibérica hace 4.500 años. El País. https://elpais.com/elpais/2018/10/01/ciencia/ 1538416630_736638.html [Accessed September 16, 2019].
Anthony, D.W. 1990. Migration in Archaeology: The Baby and the Bathwater. American Anthropologist. Vol. 92 pp. 895–914.
Anthony, D.W. 2007. The Horse, the Wheel, and Language: how Bronze-Age Riders from the Eurasian Steppes Shaped the Modern World. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Appiah, K.A. 2018. The Lies That Bind: Creed, Country, Colour, Class, Culture Main. London: Profile Books.
Barras, C. 2019. Story of most Murderous People of all time Revealed in ancient DNA. New Scientist. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg24132230-200-story-of-most-murderous-people-of-all-time-revealed-in-ancient-dna/ [Accessed April 2, 2019].
Beckerman, S.M. 2015. Corded Ware Coastal Communities: using Ceramic Analysis to Reconstruct Third Millennium BC societies in the Netherlands. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Behrens, H. 1973. Die Jungsteinzeit im Mittelelbe-Saale-Gebiet. Berlin: Landesmuseum Halle.
Bourgeois, Q. & Kroon, E. 2017. The Impact of Male Burials on the Construction of Corded Ware Identity: Reconstructing Networks of Information in the 3rd Millennium BC. PLOS ONE. Vol. 12(10) e0185971.
Brandt, G., Haak, W. [...] Cooper, A. & Alt, K.W. 2013. Ancient DNA Reveals Key Stages in the Formation of Central European Mitochondrial Genetic Diversity. Science Vol. 342(6155) pp. 257–261.
Brather, S., & Wotzka, H.-P. 2006. Alemannen und Franken? Bestattungsmodi, ethnische Identitäten und wirtschaftliche Verhältnisse in der Merowingerzeit. In: Burmeister, S. & Müller-Scheeßel, N. (eds). Soziale Gruppen - kulturelle Grenzen. Die Interpretation sozialer Identitäten in der Prähistorischen Archäologie. Tübinger Archäologische Taschenbücher, pp. 139–224. Münster/New York/München/Berlin: Waxmann.
Childe, V.G. 1929. The Danube in Prehistory. London: Clarendon Press.
Childe, V.G. 1933. Is Prehistory Practical? Antiquity Vol. 7(28) pp. 410–418.
Clarke, D.L. 1968. Analytical Archaeology. London: Methuen.
Czebreszuk, J. & Szmyt, M. 1998. Der Epochenumbruch vom Neolithikum zur Bronzezeit im Polnischen Tiefland am Beispiel Kujawiens. Praehistorische Zeitschrift. Vol. 73 pp. 167–232.
Damm, C. 1991. The Danish Single Grave Culture - Ethnic Migration or Social Construction? Journal of Danish Archaeology. Vol. 10 pp.199–204.
Eggert, M.K.H. 1978. Zum Kulturkonzept in der Prähistorischen Archäologie. Bonner Jahrbücher. Vol. 178 pp. 1–20.
Eggert, M.K.H., Müller-Scheessel, N. & Samida, S. 2012. Prähistorische Archäologie : Konzepte und Methoden Tübingen: Attempto Verlag.
Fischer, U. 1956. Die Gräber der Steinzeit im Saalegebiet. Studien über neolithische und frühbronzezeitliche Bestattungsformen in Sachsen-Thüringen. Berlin: De Gruyter.
Frieman, C. & Hofmann, D. 2019. Present Pasts in the Archaeology of Genetics, Identity, and Migration in Europe: a Critical Essay. World Archaeology online first, 26 September 2019.
Fullwiley, D. 2014. The “Contemporary Synthesis”: When Politically Inclusive Genomic Science Relies on Biological Notions of Race. Isis. Vol. 105(4) pp.803–814.
Furholt, M. 2003. Die absolutchronologische Datierung der Schnurkeramik in Mitteleuropa und Südskandinavien. Bonn: Habelt.
Furholt, M. 2008a. Culture History Beyond Cultures: The Case of the Baden Complex. In: Furholt, M., Szmyt, M., Zastawny (eds). The Baden Complex and the Outside World [Proceedings of the 12th Annual Meeting of the EAA 2006, Cracow].Studien zur Archaeologie in Ostmitteleuropa/Studia nad Pradziejami Europy Środkowej (SAO/ŚPES), pp. 13–24. Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH.
Furholt, M. 2008b. Pottery, Cultures, People? The European Baden Material Re-examined. Antiquity. Vol. 82 pp. 617–628.
Furholt, M. 2009. Die nördlichen Badener Keramikstile im Kontext des mitteleuropäischen Spätneolithikums (3650-2900 v. Chr.). Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH.
Furholt, M. 2014. Upending a ‘Totality’: Re-evaluating Corded Ware Variability in Late Neolithic Europe. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society. Vol. 80 pp. 67–86.
Furholt, M. 2016. Corded Ware and Bell Beakers – A Practice-based Perspective on Local Communities, Transregional Interaction and Social Heterogeneity in Late Neolithic Europe. In: Furholt, M., Grossmann, R. & Szmyt, M. (eds). Transitional Landscapes? The 3rd millennium BC in Europe. Proceedings of the International Workshop ‘Socio-Environmental Dynamics over the Last 12,000 Years: The Creation of Landscapes III (15th – 18th April 2013)’ in Kiel. Universitätsforschungen zur Prähistorischen Archäologie, pp. 117–131. Bonn: Habelt
Furholt, M. 2017. Das ägäische Neolithikum und Chalkolithikum - Transformationen sozialer Handlungmuster in Anatolien und Griechenland zwischen 6500 und 4000 v. Chr. Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH.
Furholt, M. 2018. Massive Migrations? The Impact of Recent aDNA Studies on our View of Third Millennium Europe. European Journal of Archaeology. Vol. 21(2) pp.159–191.
Furholt, M. 2019. Re-integrating Archaeology: A Contribution to aDNA Studies and the Migration Discourse on the 3rd Millennium BC in Europe. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society. First View, published online June 10th pp.1–15.
Furholt, M., Hinz, M. & Mischka, D. 2018. Putting Things into Practice: Exploring the Consequences of Pragmatic Theory for Archaeology. In: Haug, A., Käppel, L. & Müller J. (eds). Past Landscapes. The Dynamcs of Interaction between Society, Landscape, and Culture, pp. 87–106. Leiden: Sidestone Press
Glob, P.V. 1944. Studier over den Jyske Enkeltgravskulturen. Aarbøger. Vol. 1944 pp. 1–283.
Großmann, R. 2016. Das dialektische Verhältnis von Schnurkeramik und Glockenbecher zwischen Rhein und Saale. Bonn: Dr. Rudolf Habelt GmbH.
Haak, W., Lazaridis, I., [...]Alt, K.W. & Reich, D. 2015. Massive Migration from the Steppe was a Source for Indo-European Languages in Europe. Nature. Vol. 522(7555) pp. 207–211.
Heitz, C. & Stapfer, R. (eds.). 2017. Mobility and Pottery Production. Archaeological and Anthropological Perspectives. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Hodder, I. 1982. Symbols in Action. Ethnoarchaeological Studies of Material Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hofmann, D. 2015. What Have Genetics Ever Done for Us? The Implications of aDNA Data for Interpreting Identity in Early Neolithic Central Europe. European Journal of Archaeology. Vol. 18(3) pp. 454–476.
Ion, A. 2017. How Interdisciplinary is Interdisciplinarity? Revisiting the Impact of aDNA Research for the Archaeology of Human Remains. Current Swedish Archaeology. Vol. 25 pp. 177–198.
Iversen, R. 2010. In a World of Worlds: the Pitted Ware Complex in a Large Scale Perspective. Acta archaeologica. Vol. 81 pp. 5–43.
Iversen, R. 2015. The Transformation of Neolithic Societies: An Eastern Danish Perspective on the 3rd Millennium BC. Højbjerg: Jutland Archaeological Society.
Johannsen, N.N., Larson, G., Meltzer, D.J. & Linden, M.V. 2017. A composite window into human history. Science. Vol. 356(6343) pp. 1118–1120.
Kleijne, J. 2019. Embracing Bell Beaker. Adopting new ideas and objects across Europe during the later 3rd millennium BC (c. 2600-2000 BC). Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Kleijne, J., Beckerman, S.M., [...] van Gijn, A.L. & Zeiler, J.T. 2016. Sifting through Single Grave Settlements: Keinsmerbrug and Mienakker in the Noord Holland Tidal Area (the Netherlands). In: Furholt, M., Grossmann, R. & Szmyt, M. (eds). Transitional Landscapes? The 3rd millennium BC in Europe. Proceedings of the International Workshop ‘Socio-Environmental Dynamics over the Last 12,000 Years: The Creation of Landscapes III (15th – 18th April 2013)’ in Kiel. Universitätsforschungen zur Prähistorischen Archäologie, 171–182. Bonn: Habelt.
Knipper, C., Mittnik, A., [...]Krause, J. & Stockhammer, P. 2017. Female Exogamy and Gene Pool Diversification at the Transition from the Final Neolithic to the Early Bronze Age in Central Europe. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Vol. 114(38) pp. 10083–10088.
Kossinna, G. 1926. Ursprung und Verbreitung der Germanen in vor- und frühgeschichtlicher Zeit. Berlin: Mannus Verlag.
Kristiansen, K., Allentoft, M., [...] Sikora, M. & Willerslev, E. 2017. Re-theorising Mobility and the Formation of Culture and Language among the Corded Ware Culture in Europe. Antiquity. Vol. 91(356) pp. 334–347.
Kruk, J. 1973. Studia osadnicze nad neolitem wyżyn lessowych. Wrocław: Akademia Nauk.
Larsson, Å.M. 2009. Breaking and Making Bodies and Pots: Material and Ritual Practices in Sweden in the Third Millennium BC. Uppsala: Uppsala University.
Lüning, J. 1972. Zum Kulturbegriff im Neolithikum. Praehistorische Zeitschrift. Vol. 47 pp. 145–173.
Maran, J. & Stockhammer, P. 2012. Materiality and Social practice : Transformative Capacities of Intercultural Encounters. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Mason, P. 2019. Clear Bright Future: A Radical Defence of the Human Being. London: Penguin.
Mittnik, A., Massy, K. [...] Stockhammer, P. & Krause, J. 2019. Kinship-based Social Inequality in Bronze Age Europe. Science Vol. 10 1126/science.aax6219.
Müller, J. 2001. Soziochronologische Studien zum Jung- und Spätneolithikum im Mittelelbe-Saale-Gebiet (4100-2700 v. Chr.). Rahden (Westfalen): Leidorf.
Müller, J. 2013. Kossinna, Childe and aDNA. Comments on the Construction of Identities. Current Swedish Archaeology. Vol. 21 pp. 35–37.
Müller, J. 2015. Eight Million Neolithic Europeans: Social Demography and Social Archaeology on the Scope of Change – from the Near East to Scandinavia. In: Kristiansen, K., Šmejda, L. & Turek, J. (eds). Paradigm found: archaeological theory present, past and future; essays in honour of Evžen Neustupný, 200–214. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Müller-Scheeßel, N. 2000. Die Hallstattkultur und ihre räumliche Differenzierung: der West- und Osthallstattkreis aus forschungsgeschichtlich-methodologischer Sicht. Rahden (Westfalen): Leidorf.
Olalde, I., Brace, S., [...] Lalueza-Fox, C. & Reich, D. 2018. The Beaker Phenomenon and the Genomic Transformation of Northwest Europe. Nature. Vol. 555(7695) pp. 190–196.
Painter, N.I. 2011. The History of White People Reprint. New York: WW Norton & Co.
Preucel, R.W. 2010. Archaeological Semiotics. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Rascovan, N., Sjögren, K.-G., [...] Desnues, Ch. & Rasmussen, S. 2018. Emergence and Spread of Basal Lineages of Yersinia pestis during the Neolithic Decline. Cell. Vol. 176(1) pp. 295-305.
Roberts, B.W. & Vander Linden, M. (eds.). 2011. Investigating Archaeological Cultures. New York, NY: Springer New York.
Sangmeister, E. 1966. Die Datierung des Rückstroms der Glockenbecher und ihre Auswirkung auf die Chronologie der Kupferzeit in Portugal (Abb. 1-2). Palaeohistoria. Vol. 12 pp. 395–407.
Schroeder, H., Margaryan, A., [...] Johannsen, N.N. & Allentoft, M. 2019. Unraveling Ancestry, Kinship, and Violence in a Late Neolithic Mass Grave. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. Vol. 116(22) pp. 10705–10710.
Schultrich, S. 2019. Das Jungneolithikum in Schleswig-Holstein. Leiden: Sidestone Press.
Shennan, S. 1989. Introduction: Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity. In: Shennan, S. (ed). Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity, 1–32. London: Unwin Hyman.
Shennan, S.J. 1976. Bell Beakers and their Context in Central Europe. In: Lanting J.N. & van der Waals J.D. (eds.). Glockenbechersymposium Oberried 1974, 231–240. Oberried: Fibula-Van Dishoeck.
Sherratt, A. 1981. Plough and Pastoralism: Aspects of the Secondary Products Revolution. In: Hodder, I., Isaac, G. & Hammond, N. (eds). Pattern of the past. Studies in honour of David Clarke, 261–305. Cambridge: University Press.
Strahm, C. 1971. Die Gliederung der Schnurkeramischen Kultur in der Schweiz. Bern: Stämpfli & Cie.
Strahm, C. 2002. Tradition und Wandel der sozialen Strukturen vom 3. zum 2. vorchristlichen Jahrtausend. In: Müller, J. (ed). Vom Endneolithikum zur Frühbronzezeit: Muster sozialen Wandels? (Tagung Bamberg 14.-16. Juni 2001). Universitätsforschungen zur Prähistorischen Archäologie, 175–194. Bonn: Habelt
Strahm, C. 2010. Endneolithische Siedlungsmuster. In: Matuschik I. & Strahm C. (eds). Vernetzungen. Aspekte siedlungsarchäologischer Forschung. Festschrift für Helmut Schlichterle zum 60. Geburtstag, 317–330. Freiburg: Lavori Verlag.
Struve, K.W. 1955. Die Einzelgrabkultur in Schleswig-Holstein. Neumünster: Wachholtz
Suter, P. 2017. Um 2700 v. Chr. Wandel und Kontinuität in den Ufersiedlungen am Bielersee. Bern: Archäologischer Dienst des Kantons Bern.
Valera, A.C. & Criado Boado, F. 2018. Genética de una “fake news”: respuesta a las noticias sobre “invasiones” y “exterminios” en el III milenio Antes de Nuestra Era en la Península Ibérica. Las gafas de Childe. https://lasgafasdechilde.es/genetica-de-una-fake-news-respuesta-a-las-noticias-sobre-invasiones-y-exterminios-en-el-iii-milenio-antes-de-nuestra-era-en-la-peninsula-iberica/ [Accessed September 16, 2019].
Vander Linden, M. 2006. Le phénomène campaniforme dans l’Europe du 3ème millénaire avant notre ère: synthèse et nouvelles perspectives. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Vander Linden, M. 2007. What Linked the Bell Beakers in the Third Millennium Europe? Antiquity. Vol. 81 pp. 343–352.
Vander Linden, M. 2016. Population History in Third-Millennium-BC Europe: Assessing the Contribution of Genetics. World Archaeology. Vol. 48(5) pp. 714–728.
Veeramah, K.R. 2018. The Importance of Fine-scale Studies for Integrating Paleogenomics and Archaeology. Current Opinion in Genetics & Development. Vol. 53 pp. 83–89.
Veit, U. 1989. Ethnic Concepts in German Prehistory: A Case Study on the Relationship between Cultural Identity and Archaeological Objectivity. In: Shennan, S. (ed). Archaeological Approaches to Cultural Identity, 35-55. London: Routledge.
Wenger, E. 1998. Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning, and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wotzka, H.-P. 1993. Zum traditionellen Kulturbegriff in der prähistorischen Archäologie. Paideuma. Vol. 39 pp. 25–44.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Authors contributing to Current Swedish Archaeology retain copyright of their work, with first publication rights granted to the Swedish Archaeological Society. Read the journal's full Copyright- and Licensing Policy.
