Professionalism in action – Music teachers on an assessment journey
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24834/educare.2015.2.1132Keywords:
assessment, John Dewey, music education, participatory action research, upper secondary schoolAbstract
The points of departure in this article are questions regarding assessment in music education. These are related to issues of professional responsibility and accountability as well as a holistic view on education as conceptualized in Deweyean pragmatism and concern the risk of criteria compliance. A participatory action research project in a Swedish Upper secondary school focusing on assessment of music is presented, where the purpose of the research was to develop knowledge about music teachers’ experience and conceptualizations regarding assessment practices within the frame of the National Arts Programme. This is enabled by asking the following research questions: In what ways do teachers conceptualize musical knowledge and learning and educational communication in relation to assessment? What qualities appear within the teachers’ conceptualizations regarding knowledge, learning, communication and assessment of students’ knowledge? Aims from the field of praxis were integrated in the project, with focus on equivalent assessment and legal certainty. Results from the research project show the music teachers’ ability to shift between atomistic and holistic perspectives but at the same time keep their holistic view of assessment and learning. Equivalence is according to the teachers something different than uniformity, and is only possible through reflection and collaboration, internally as well as externally with other practitioners.
References
Allsup, Randall E. & Westerlund, Heidi (2012). Methods and situational ethics in music education. Action, Criticism, and Theory for Music Education, 11(1), 124–148. http://act.maydaygroup.org/articles/Allsup Westerlund11_1.pdf
Apple, Michael W. (2004). Creating Difference: Neo-Liberalism, Neo-Conservatism and the Politics of Educational Reform. Educational Policy, 18(Jan./March), 12-44.
Biesta, Gert (2007). Why “What Works” Won’t Work: Evidencebased Practice and Democratic Deficit in Educational Research. Educational The-ory, 57(1), 1-22.
Beach, Dennis, Bagley, Carl, Eriksson, Anita, Player-Koro, Catarina (2014). Changing teacher education in Sweden: Using metaethnographicanalysis to understand and describe policy making and educational changes. Teaching and Teacher Education, 44 (2014), 160-167.
Björk, Maj & Johansson, Monica (1996). Dubbellogg – ett redskap för reflektion och lärande. In Birgit Lendahls & U. Runesson (Eds.), Vägar till lärares lärande (pp. 52-67). Lund: Studentlitteratur.
Boman, Ylva, Ljunggren, Carsten & von Wright, Moira (2007). Variationer av pragmatism. In Ylva Boman, C. Ljunggren & M. von Wright (Eds.), Erfarenheter av pragmatism (pp. 13-22). Lund: Studentlitteratur.
Bresler, Liora (1995/2006). Ethnography, Phenomenology And Action Research In Music Education. Quarterly Journal of Music Teaching and Learning, 6(3), 4-16. Reprinted with permission in Visions of Research in Music Education, 16(6), Autumn, 2010.
Broady, Donald (2012). Bildningstankens krumbukter. Några blad ur historien från 1970-tal till 2010-tal. In Anders Burman & P. Sundgren (Eds.), Svenska bildningstraditioner (pp. 285-308). Daidalos, Göteborg.
Burman, Anders (2014). Dewey och den reflekterade erfarenheten. In Anders Burman (Ed.), Den reflekterade erfarenheten. John Dewey om demokrati, utbildning och tänkande (pp. 13-36). Huddinge: Södertörns högskola.
Cain, Tim, Holmes, Melanie, Larrett, Alison & Mattock, Joanna (2007). Literature-Informed, One-Turn Action Research: Three Cases and a Commentary. British Educational Research Journal, 33(1), 91-106.
Cain, Tim (2008). The characteristics of action research in music education. British Journal of Music Education, 25(3), 283–313.
Carlgren, Ingrid (2013). Hur lärare ska få kunskap bestäms uppifrån. Rev. September 16, 2013. Online: http://www.skolaochsamhalle.se/flode/skolpolitik/ingrid-carlgren-kunskapsimplementering-genompabjuden-kollegialitet/ September 18.
Colwell, Richard (2003). The Status of Arts Assessment: Examples from Music. Arts Education Policy Review, 105(2), 11-18.
Davidson, Rolf (1980). Svensk musikundervisning på 1950-talet – Några personliga reflektioner kring det som blev tänkt och gjort. Svensk Tidskrift för Musikforskning, 1980(1), 141-157.
Denscombe, Martyn. (2014). The Good Research Guide. For smallscale social research projects. Berkshire: Open University Press.
Dewey, John (1915). The Logic of Judgments of Practise. The Journal of Philosophy, Psychology and Scientific Methods, 12(20), 533-543.
Dewey, John (1916). Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education. Web-edition. New York: Columbia University.
Dewey, John (1929). The Quest for Certainty. A Study of the Relation of Knowledge and Action. London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd.
Dewey, John (1934). Art As Experience. New York: Perigree/Penguin Group.
Dewey, John (1938a). Experience and Education. New York: Touchstone.
Dewey, John (1938b). Logic – The Theory of Inquiry. New York: Henry Holt and Company.
Dewey, John (1958). Experience and nature. New York: Dover Publications.
Dewey, John (1987). The later works of John Dewey, 1925–1953. Essays, Reviews, Trotsky Inquiry, Miscellany and Liberalism and Social Action, J. A. Boydston (Ed.), vol. 11, Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press.
Dewey, John (2004). Individ, skola och samhälle. Utbildningsfilosofiska texter. Sven Hartman, U. P. Lundgren & R. M. Hartman (Eds.). Stockholm: Natur & Kultur.
Englund, Tomas (2000). Rethinking democracy and education: towards an education of deliberative citizens. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 32(2), 305–313.
Englund, Tomas (2011). The linguistic turn within curriculum theory. Pedagogy, Culture and Society, 19(2), 193-206.
Evaldsson, Ann-Carita (2003). Mångkulturalitet och jämställdhet i vardaglig skolverksamhet. In Ingrid Carlgren, I. Josefson & C. Liberg (Eds.), Forskning av denna världen – praxisnära forskning inom utbildningsvetenskap (pp. 27-34). Stockholm: The Swedish Research Council.
Fautley, Martin (2010). Assessment in Music Education. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ferm Thorgersen, Cecilia (2011). Assessment of musical knowledge from a life-world-phenomenological perspective – challenges of conceptualising and communication. Hellenic Journal of Music, Education and Culture, 2(1), 37-45.
Ferm Thorgersen, Cecilia & Schwieler, Elias (2014). Translating the impossible: listening, learning, and art. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 47(4), in press.
Ferm Thorgersen, Cecilia, Zandén, Olle, Vinge, John, Väkevä, Lauri, Andersson, Ninnie & Nyberg, Johan (2014). Assessment as learning in music education – the risk of ‘criteria compliance’ replacing ’learning’ in the Scandinavian countries. Conference symposium on assessment, Knowledge Formation in Music. NNMPF Conference, 23-25 April 2014, the Royal College of Music, Stockholm.
Franzén, Bengt (1959). Att bedöma musikelever. Stockholm: Nordiska musikförlaget.
Handal, Gunnar (1999). Consultation Using Critical Friends. New Directions For Teaching and Learning, 79(fall), 59-70.
Holmstrand, Lars (2006). Deltagarorienterad aktionsforskning – ett nytt paradigm. In Birgitta Wingård (Ed.), Livslång nyfikenhet. En vänbok till Gunilla Härnsten (pp. 125-139). Stockholm: HLS förlag.
Irwin, Rita L. & Chalmers, F. Graeme (2007). Experiencing the visual and visualizing the experiences. In Liora Bresler (Ed.), International Hand-book of Research in Arts Education (pp. 178-194). Dordrecht: Springer.
Isaacs, William N. (1993). Taking Flight: Dialogue, Collective Thinking, and Organizational Learning. Organizational Dynamics, 22(2), 24-39.
Isaacs, William N. (2001) Toward an Action Theory of Dialogue, International Journal of Public Administration, 24(7-8), 709-748
Jefferson, Gail (2004). Glossary of transcript symbols with an introduction. In Gene H. Lerner (Ed.), Conversation Analysis – Studies from the first generation (pp. 13-34). Amsterdam: John Benjamins B.V.
Klapp Lekholm, Alli (2010). Lärares betygsättningspraktik. Forskning om undervisning och lärande. Bedömning för lärande – en grund för ökat kunnande, 3(Jan.). Stockholm: Stiftelsen SAF i samverkan med Lärarförbundet.
Lerner, Gene H. (2004). Introductory remarks. In Gene H. Lerner (Ed.), Conversation Analysis – Studies from the first generation (pp. 13-34). Amsterdam: John Benjamins B.V.
Lewin, Kurt (1946). Action Research and Minority Problems. Journal of Social Issues, 4(2), 34-46.
Liedman, Sven-Eric (2011). Hets! En bok om skolan. Falun: Albert Bonniers förlag.
Lilja, Peter (2014). Negotiating Teacher Professionalism. On the Symbolic Politics of Sweden’s Teacher Unions. Malmö: Malmö University, Faculty of Education and Society
Lundahl, Christian (2011). Bedömning för lärande. Stockholm: Norstedts.
Nielsen, Frede V. (2002). Quality and Value in the Interpretation of Music from a Phenomenological Point of View – a Draft. Zeitschrift für Kritische Musikpädagogik, http://home.arcor.de/zf/zfkm/nielsen1.pdf
Nordin, Andreas (2012). Kunskapens politik – en studie av kunskapsdiskurser i svensk och europeisk utbildningspolicy. Växjö: Linnaeus University Press.
Oxenswärdh, Anette (2011). Ansvarsförhållanden vid skolutveckling. Stockholm: Institutionen för pedagogik och didaktik, Stockholms universitet.
Phillips, Louise J., Kristiansen, Marianne, Vehviläinen, Marja & Gunnarsson, Ewa (2013). Tackling the Tensions of Dialogue and Participation – Reflexive Strategies for Collaborative Research. In Louise J. Phillips, M. Kristiansen, M. Vehviläinen & E. Gunnarsson (Eds.), Knowledge and Power in Collaborative Research – A Reflexive Approach (pp. 1-18). New York: Routledge.
Reason, Peter (2003). Pragmatist Philosophy and Action Research: Readings and Conversation with Richard Rorty. Action Research, 1(1), 103-123.
Reason, Peter (2006). Choice and Quality in Action Research Practice. Journal of Management Inquiry, 15(June), 187-203.
Regelski, Thomas A. (2009). Curriculum Reform: Reclaiming “Music” as Social Praxis. Action, Criticism, and Theory for Music Education, 8(1), 66-84. http://act.maydaygroup.org/articles/Regelski8_1.pdf
Rönnerman, Karin (2000). Att växa som pedagog. Utvärdering av ett aktionsforskningsprojekt i förskolan. Göteborg: Göteborgs universitet.
Rönnerman, Karin (2004). Aktionsforskning i praktiken. Lund: Studentlitteratur.
Sadler, D. Royce (1989). Formative assessment and the design of instructional systems. Instructional Science, 18(2), 119-144.
Sadler, D. Royce (2009). Indeterminacy in the use of preset criteria for assessment and grading. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher
Sandberg, Ralf (1996). Musikundervisningens yttre villkor och inre liv. Några variationer över ett läroplansteoretiskt tema. Stockholm: HLS förlag. SFS 2010:800 Skollag. Utbildningsdepartementet.
Sjöberg, Robert (2010). Balansakten bedömning – kontinuitet och transformation. Svenska språklärares bedömning och betygssättning som uppdrag, praktik och kompetens i förändring. Göteborg: Göteborgs universitet.
Smylie, Mark A. (1996). From Bureaucratic Control to Building Human Capital: The Importance of Teacher Learning in Education Reform Educational Researcher, 25(9), 9-11.
Solbrekke, Tone Dyrdal & Englund, Tomas (2011). Bringing professional responsibility back in, Studies In Higher Education, 36(Jan.), 847-861.
Stanley, Anne Marie (2009). The experiences of elementary music teachers in a collaborative teacher study group. Michigan: UMI Publishing.
Stedt, Lisbeth (2013). Samarbete och lärande. Om friktion, uppgifters komplexitet och erfarenhetsutbyten i samarbete. Stockholm: Stockholms universitet.
Svensson, Lennart (2002). Bakgrund och utgångspunkter. In Lennart Svensson, G. Brulin, P-E. Ellström & Ö. Widegren (Eds.), Arbetsliv i omvandling. Interaktiv forskning – för utveckling av teori och praktik (pp. 1-22). Stockholm: Arbetslivsinstitutet.
The Swedish National Agency for Education (2011). Programstruktur, Estetiska programmet. Online: www.skolverket.se. January 9. The Swedish Research Council (2002). Online: www.codex.vr.se/texts/HSFR.pdf, May 3.
The Swedish Schools Inspectorate. (2012). Nationella prov med upp-satsskrivning stöder inte likvärdig betygssättning. Press announcement 8/31/12. Online: http://www.skolinspektionen.se/sv/Om-oss/Press/Pressmeddelanden/Nationella-prov-med-uppsatsskrivning-stoder-inte-likvardig-betygssattning/ October 3.
Timperley, Helen, Wilson, Aaron, Barrar, Heather & Fung, Irene (2007). Teacher Professional Learning and Development – Best Evidence Synthesis Iteration [BES]. Auckland: New Zealand Ministry of Education.
Timperley, Helen (2011). Knowledge and the Leadership of Learning, Leadership and Policy in Schools, 10(2), 145-170.
Torrance, Harry (2007). Assessment as learning? Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 14(3), 281-294.
Varkøy, Øivind (2007). Instrumentalism in the Field of Music Education: Are We All Humanists? Philosophy of Music Education Review, 15(1), 37-52.
Vinge, John (2014). Vurdering i musikkfag – En deskriptiv, analytisk studieav musikklæreres vurderingspraksis i ungdomsskolen. Oslo: Norgesmusikkhøgskole.
Väkevä, Lauri (2007). Art Education, The Art of Education and the Art of Life. Considering the Implications of Dewey’s Later Philosophy to Art and music Education. Action, Criticism, and Theory for MusicEducation, 6(1), 2-15. http://act.maydaygroup.org/articles/Vakeva6_1.pdf
Väkevä, Lauri & Westerlund, Heidi (2007). The ”Method” of Democracy in Music Education, Action, Criticism, and Theory for Music Education, 6(4), 96-108.
Wiliam, Dylan (2011). Embedded Formative Assessment. Bloomington: Solution tree.
Winther Jørgensen, Marianne (2008). På framkant: Interaktiv forskning och vetenskapens plats i samhället. In Bengt Johannisson, E. Gunnarsson & T. Stjernberg (Eds.), Gemensamt kunskapande – den interaktiva forskningens praktik (pp. 349-366). Växjö: Växjö University Press.
Zandén, Olle (2010). Samtal om samspel. Kvalitetsuppfattningar musiklärares dialoger om ensemblespel på gymnasiet. Göteborg: Nämnden för konstnärligt utvecklingsarbete, Konstnärliga fakulteten, Göteborgs universitet.
Zandén, Olle (2011). Professionalise or perish. A case for heightened educational quality through collegiate cooperation. In Sven-Erik Holgersen & S. Graabræk Nielsen (Eds.), Nordisk musikpedagogisk forskning (pp. 117-134). Oslo: Norges musikkhøgskole.
Zandén, Olle (2013). Till en kritik av tydlighetsdoktrinen. Conference presentation Nordiskt nätverk för musikpedagogisk forskning (NNMPF), Feb. 27-March 1. Bergen, Norway.
